Practice Guide: Multispecies Cropping
PART OF A SERIES OF PRACTICE GUIDES TO USED IN YOUR REGENERATIVE CROPPING TOOLSET | LAST UPDATED: OCTOBER 2024
Overview
Multispecies cropping involves the use of multiple crop species from diverse plant families at the same time. The practice is often used to bring diversity into farming systems, transition ‘problem’ paddocks and build farm resilience.
This guide is an introduction to multispecies cropping.11 Multispecies pasture cropping, intercropping and companion cropping are related practices that are not covered in this guide.It covers the benefits of this practice, decisions on what seeds to use, application methods, complementary practices and what to look for to know if your multispecies crops are working. Like all practices, it must be considered in the unique context of each farm. For this reason, the guide shares three different examples of how farmers have integrated multispecies into their diverse operations in Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia.
Before trying a new practice, it is important to consider your unique context and goals. What are you trying to achieve? Soil and landscape ecosystems are complex, and no two farming systems are the same – what worked for one farmer may not work for you. So consider starting small, monitoring the results and allowing some room for trial and error. There is no silver bullet when it comes to addressing soil health, so think about which strategies or combinations of other practices may be suitable to support what you’re doing.
Important: This Guide is designed to provide general information only. It is not tailored to the context of any individual farm, person or business, and does not constitute advice. Before using the information, you should carefully evaluate its accuracy, currency, completeness and relevance for your purposes, and consider seeking advice from appropriate professionals who have taken into account your individual circumstances and objectives. As a nonprofit dedicated to supporting farmers, we work hard to ensure our information is useful and accurate. However, Soils for Life accepts no liability arising from any use or release of information in, or referred to in or linked to this guide, or any error, inaccuracy or omission.
Other guides to check out
What is multispecies cropping?
Multispecies cropping is the integration of multiple species from diverse plant families into a single paddock, usually as part of a cropping or grazing rotation. Multispecies crops can be used as a cover crop to protect and improve the soil and prepare for the following crop, as feed for livestock and/or as a cash crop.
Farmers often complement multispecies cropping with practices such as biological seed treatments and foliar applications. See our guides on biological seed treatments and foliar applications (forthcoming) for more on these practices.
Video 1. Farmer Grant Sims from Down Under Covers explains how he uses multispecies cropping on his farm and how and why he started.
Farmers who are planting multispecies crops
This guide includes examples from three Australian farmers throughout, showing their approach to multispecies cropping in their diverse farming systems in Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia.
Grant Sims is a sixth generation farmer running cattle, growing a range of cereal, legume and oil seed crops, and producing and selling multispecies seed mixes at Pine Grove near Lockington, Victoria.
Concerned for his family’s health and the health of the farm, he immediately stopped using fungicides, insecticides and synthetic fertilisers when he came back to the farm to work full time in 2008. While exploring ways to transition the farm and bring in diversity, he ‘stumbled upon’ multispecies cropping, which is now an integral part of his farm and livestock management. Grant also uses biological seed treatments and foliar applications, and is always experimenting with practices that build soil health, because he believes that ‘healthy soils produce healthy plants, animals and kids’.
Location: Dja Dja Wurrung Country, Lockington, VIC
Regional Climate: Hot dry summer, cold winter/Mediterranean OR Temperate cool season wet
Average Annual Rainfall: 435 mm
Property Size: 3440 ha
Elevation: 103 m
Social Structure: Family farm
Enterprise Type: Cropping, beef cattle, occasional trade lambs, multispecies seed mixes
Multispecies uses: Livestock feed (incl. to improve weight gain), to improve soil and nutrient/moisture availability, seed mixes
Soils: Red and brown Sodosols
Ian Beard has been growing grain and melons and running cattle since the 1980s when he stopped working as a builder. Ian and Sharon now live on an 80 ha former dairy farm (Hillcrest) in Wyreema, just outside of Toowoomba, in southern Queensland where Ian grows dryland cereal crops.
When they arrived on the farm four years ago, some areas of the property were ‘so degraded’ that they required extensive earthworks to create some viable top soil. For the last 10 years, Ian has used multispecies cover cropping in conjunction with seed treatments and foliar applications of nutrients and biologicals. Acutely aware of moisture in the landscape, he is constantly refining his choice of crops and approach to implementing multispecies cropping to suit changing conditions.
Location: Giabal Country
Wyreema, QLD
Regional Climate: Warm summer, cold winter/ Temperate cool season wet
Average Annual Rainfall: 683 mm (recent, 1994-2023)
Property Size: 80 ha
Elevation: 530 m
Social Structure: Family farm
Enterprise Type: Grain
Multispecies uses: Part of crop rotation, to improve soils, cash crops
Soils: Combination of Vertosols (near the creek) and Dermosols (on sloping country)
Rob and Judi Hetherington have been managing the family farm (Walma) in the Lake district of the south-eastern wheatbelt in Western Australia since the 1980s. Now 100% cropping, they grow grains, oil seed, legumes and multispecies cash crops.
Rob has trialled many practices over the years including green manures, landscape rehydration, calcium ameliorations, companion planting, biological stimulants, and more recently, multispecies cropping. Multispecies cropping now makes up 30% of his annual cropping rotation, and the entire multispecies crop goes direct to a dairy. Central to Rob’s approach is the health of the soil and plants, and in turn animals and humans.
Location: Nyaki-Nyaki Country
Lake King, WA
Regional Climate: Warm summer, cold winter/ Mediterranean
Average Annual Rainfall: 330 mm (Lake King)
Property Size: 2,500 ha
Elevation: 50 m
Social Structure: Family farm
Enterprise Type: Winter cropping and sometimes summer cropping of cereals, oil seeds and legumes
Multispecies uses: Cash crop for dairy, to improve soils
Soils: Calcarosol soils, often called mallee sand, mallee loam or calcareous earths
What are the benefits?
An effective way to build soil health, improve nutrient cycling and boost productivity
There is no single solution when it comes to improving soil and farm resilience, but multispecies cropping can be an effective tool to start building your soil health and potentially reap financial benefits too.
Diagram 1. Four plant families (left to right – Poaceae, Brassicaceae, Fabaceae, Asteraceae) showing diverse roots and leaf structures, and some of the benefits of multispecies crops. Source: Soils for Life
Build soil biology: The diversity of plants in a multispecies crop can stimulate soil biology, which in turn feeds plants.22See for example, Christine Jones, “Enhancing the plant-associated soil microbiome,” in List of Plant Families, Lower Blackwood Catchment, accessed 3 September 2024, https://lowerblackwood.com.au/list-of-plant-families-for-enhancing-the-plant-associated-soil-microbiome-jones-2023/ Multispecies crops have a greater variety of root and leaf sizes and shapes compared to a monoculture crop. Greater leaf variety allows more sunlight to be captured and used for photosynthesis. Increased photosynthesis enables the plants to produce more root exudates,3Root exudates are organic carbon compounds (e.g. simple sugars, organic acids and amino acids) secreted from living plant roots into the soil. which stimulate biological activity and build soil humus,4“The new science behind biodiversity, cover crops and building the soil sociobiome: learnings from Dr. Christine Jones,” Vidacycle, accessed July 26, 2024. https://soils.vidacycle.com/blog/science-biodiversity-covercrops-building-the-soil-sociobiome which in turn enables increased plant uptake of nutrients via ‘rhizophagy’.5This is the process whereby plant roots engulf organisms and strip them of their nutrients. Crop diversity can also increase and diversify mycorrhizal fungi communities.6Aidee Guzman, Marisol Montes, Leslie Hutchins, Gisel DeLaCerda, Paula Yang, Anne Kakouridis, Ruth M. Dahlquist-Willard, Mary K. Firestone, Timothy Bowles, Claire Kremen, “Crop diversity enriches arbuscular mycorrhizal fungal communities in an intensive agricultural landscape,” New Phytol, 231 (2021): 447-459. https://doi.org/10.1111/nph.17306 When plant roots develop beneficial relationships with these fungi, it can result in improved water and nutrient acquisition and uptake for the plant.7Wahab, Abdul, Murad Muhammad, Asma Munir, Gholamreza Abdi, Wajid Zaman, Asma Ayaz, Chandni Khizar, and Sneha Priya Pappula Reddy, “Role of Arbuscular Mycorrhizal Fungi in Regulating Growth, Enhancing Productivity, and Potentially Influencing Ecosystems under Abiotic and Biotic Stresses.” Plants 12, no. 17 (2023): 3102. https://doi.org/10.3390/plants12173102,8 “Are Cover Crops the Answer?” Integrity Soils, accessed July 26, 2024. https://integritysoils.com/blogs/articles/are-cover-crops-the-answer?_pos=1&_sid=e6f53289c&_ss=r
Improve nutrient cycling: Different plant groups employ different strategies to access nutrients, so more diversity of plants generally means access to more nutrients. For example, fibrous roots capture nutrients from a wide but shallow area, whereas tap roots access nutrients deeper in the soil. Some plants can enhance the availability of certain nutrients, for example, in some cases buckwheat and lupins are good at accessing phosphorus.9Chen S, Yang D, Wei Y, He L, Li Z, Yang S, “Changes in Soil Phosphorus Availability and Microbial Community Structures in Rhizospheres of Oilseed Rapes Induced by Intercropping with White Lupins,” Microorganisms 11, no. 2 (2023):326. doi: 10.3390/microorganisms11020326,10 Jasper M. Tehoh and David W Franzen, “Buckwheat (Fagopyrum escelentum) Potential to Contribute Solubilized Soil Phosphorus to Subsequent Crops,” Communications in Soils Science and Plant Analysis, 42 (2011): 1544-1550. doi:10.1080/00103624.2011.581724 Legumes are an important inclusion to multispecies mixes, as they can form beneficial relationships with the nitrogen-fixing bacteria rhizobia.11 Wang Q, Liu J, Zhu H, “Genetic and Molecular Mechanisms Underlying Symbiotic Specificity in Legume-Rhizobium Interactions,” Front Plant Sci., 9 (2018):313. doi:10.3389/fpls.2018.00313 Multispecies cover crops can also help reduce nitrogen losses and retain nitrogen in an accessible and stable organic form.12 “Mixed Cover Crops for Sustainable Farms,” CSIRO, accessed August 2024, https://research.csiro.au/mixedcovercrops/project-updates/ For example, reportedly tubers are great accumulators of nitrogen, which means nitrogen won’t be leached through the profile or lost to volatilisation.13Volatisation is the conversion of a liquid to a gas, in this case ammonia. Additional biomass can be generated through multispecies cover crops14Qasim A. Khan and Kent A. McVay, “Productivity and Stability of Multi-Species Cover Crop Mixtures in the Northern Great Plains,” Crop Economics, Production and Management 11, no. 4 (2019):1817-1827, doi.org/10.2134/agronj2018.03.0173 and this can also support nutrient cycling and the development of soil organic matter.
Restore soil structure: Multispecies crops can help improve the structure of soil by reducing compaction,15Norman Gentsch, Florin Laura Riechers, Jens Boy, Dörte Schweneker, Ulf Feuerstein, Diana Heuermann, and Georg Guggenberger, “Cover crops improve soil structure and change organic carbon distribution in macroaggregate fractions,” Soil 10, no. 1 (2024): 139–150, doi.org/10.5194/soil-10-139-2024 stabilising soil (reducing erosion) and improving water infiltration and holding capacity. For example, some farmers find that the large tap roots of some radishes help break up soil compaction and the extensive root systems of plants such as sunflowers help to aggregate soil and improve water infiltration. Plants can be an alternative to ripping, or as Grant Sims says, ‘use roots not iron’. Plant diversity also supports a healthy microbial community, which can also improve soil structure.
Build resilience: Pests and disease tend to thrive in a monoculture. Increasing biodiversity into a farming system, including through multispecies cover cropping, can help break pest and disease cycles and attract beneficial insects and pollinators. Plant diversity can also support healthy soil, which in turn supports healthy plants that can withstand environmental stress. For example, when plants experience environmental stress they can ‘call for help’ and ingest microbes in the soil that then switch on genes that support the plant.16“The new science behind biodiversity, cover crops and building the soil sociobiome: learnings from Dr. Christine Jones” Additionally, multispecies crops can reduce weed pressure through a number of mechanisms, for example by taking up the ‘ecological space’ that weeds might otherwise fill or by increasing competition with weeds through diverse ground cover.17 Cindy Benjamin, “Can multi-species planting provide effective weed control?” November 21, 2021, https://www.weedsmart.org.au/content/can-multi-species-planting-provide-effective-weed-control/
Boost productivity and financial gains: Multispecies can have many benefits to productivity and finances in both mixed cropping/livestock and 100% cropping systems. If animals are a part of the system, using multispecies pastures as fodder can have net financial benefit through increased live weight gains.18“Animal Performance (weight gain),” Watershed Landcare Incorporated, “Animal Performance (weight gain),” accessed July 26, 2024. https://watershedlandcare.com.au/projects/multispecies-forage-crops-for-lamb-production-soil-carbon-sequestration-and-offsetting-livestock-emissions/animal-performance-weight-gain/ These crops can also extend seasonal feed and increase the variety of forage, and therefore nutrients, available for animals. In both contexts, direct financial benefits can be seen if the crop is harvested as a cash crop or if seeds are harvested and sold, or kept for future seed mixes. Some farmers have observed that multispecies can help to improve soil for following crops, often reducing the need for inputs.19Some studies also support a reduced need for inputs, see for example Jasper et al. “Buckwheat,” 2011 and Mary B. Lynch, Fionnuala Godwin, Tommy M. Boland, Alan K. Kelly, Alexander C.O. Evans, Paul N.C. Murphy, Helen Sheridan, “Multispecies swards outperform perennial ryegrass under intensive beef grazing,” Agriculture, Ecosystems & Environment 345, (2023):108335, doi.org/10.1016/j.agee.2022.108335. Improved water efficiency (through improved soil structure, water infiltration and reduced evaporation through groundcover) can also improve yields.20 “Are Cover Crops the Answer?” Integrity Soils, accessed July 26, 2024. https://integritysoils.com/blogs/articles/are-cover-crops-the-answer?_pos=1&_sid=e6f53289c&_ss=r
For Grant Sims (Lockington, VIC), growing multispecies crops has been an effective way to manage his soils through extreme weather conditions and to realise direct financial and productivity benefits through livestock and his seed business. Multispecies crops have helped Grant to build soil structure, increase fungi and microbes in the soil, and increase the biomass and mineral density of plants. They have been an important part of his strategy to reduce inputs, and have paved the way to virtually eliminating fungicides and insecticides from his enterprise.
‘In that first year the crop grew to a foot over my ute…the amount of biomass was amazing! Things like beans, lupins which don’t typically grow well on their own in sodic soils, were doing amazing.’ Grant Sims
Grant’s livestock can ‘harvest’ the biomass of his multispecies crops and convert it into live weight gains, which he says are higher than when livestock are fed on a monoculture crop. At 1.7-2 kg/day, his animals’ weight gains are almost double the industry benchmark of 1 kg/day. Grant also harvests the seed and creates multispecies mixes for other farmers to use.
In 2014, Ian and Sharon (Wyreema, QLD) purchased an established melon farm in Chinchilla with their daughter Emily and son in-law Tom, but the soil was so poor that melons would no longer grow. Tom suggested they trial tillage radish. After putting out some seed, Ian was soon convinced to start experimenting with multispecies because ‘the results were just outstanding.’ The multispecies cover crop completely changed the soils that they had been trying to change for years.
Now on their current property ‘Hillcrest’ and with 10 years of experience with multispecies, Ian uses multispecies cover crops between each cash crop to accelerate photosynthesis and increase plant growth in the paddock ‘to give us more sugars and more bang for our buck.’ He says that every time he grows a multispecies crop, the plant biomass is so much greater than the monoculture paddock next to it. He has also observed weed suppression and an abundance of beneficial insects.
‘The multispecies cover crop physically changed the soil, the crop following it and everything else that went with it, [such as] less weed pressure…’ Ian Beard
Rob Hetherington (Lake King, WA) first put in a five-way summer multispecies crop in 2015. The crop included millet, cowpea, safflower, sunflowers and lablab. He then started experimenting with companion planting (chickpeas with canola and lupins with canola) and a winter multispecies mix (wheat, barley, cereal rye, faba beans, lupins, vetch and some canola). Initially he ploughed in one multispecies paddock as a green manure and harvested another to be graded and sold as seed. In 2021, a market became available to sell the multispecies crop as feed to a dairy. The dairy asked for more in 2022, prompting Rob to become ‘more serious’ about multispecies cropping. With the dairy contract, they have a cash crop which they can send ungraded straight from the header. The dairy is very happy with the health benefits for their cows and the quantity and quality of milk they are producing, and Rob is happy with how his soils are responding to the multispecies rotations.
How to sow and manage a multispecies crop
Multispecies crops are much like any other crop, with some additional considerations. Generally, you will need to think about:
- Choosing the right mix of plants
- Giving the crop a good start
- Preparing and sowing the seed
- Supporting the crop
- Harvesting, termination and utilisation
Remember that taking small steps over time rather than going ‘all in’ can help you to manage risk and allow your system to adjust. It can take time to learn how best to implement and adjust multispecies (e.g. seed mixes, ratios, sowing time, etc.) to your evolving context. You can consider running one or more trial paddocks to experiment with different seed mixes and monitoring the results until you feel confident to implement at a larger scale.
Video 2. Sixth generation farmer Grant Sims talks about how he sows and manages his multispecies crops. (Note this video has six different topics, you’ll find them on the video timeline)
Choosing plant mixes
Diversity of plant families is key: When considering seed mixes, ensuring a diversity of plant ‘functional groups’ or ‘families’ is critical.21Species that share morphological, phenological, and physiological traits, such as in the case of plant families) are more important than total species diversity. See research from the Jena Experiment https://the-jena-experiment.de/ While some farmers use a set number of plant families, others recommend a range (e.g. 4 to 6 different families). Plant families are often selected for specific desired characteristics (e.g. medicinal properties for livestock, breaking down hard soil pans, or including certain root exudates that can facilitate phosphorus availability) and to bring in diverse and complementary root systems. Different plant families can also be used for summer or winter planting depending on the farm context (e.g. in low rainfall areas, some farmers only sow summer mixes when soil moisture is adequate and terminate the crop before peak flowering to conserve soil moisture). Seed mixes can be sourced from a commercial supplier tailored to your needs and season, or you can source your own seed and start with a smaller mix of what’s locally available. Depending on their context, enterprise mix, rotation goals and end use (e.g. cash crop or cover crop), many farmers choose to begin with annuals.
Choose plants that are right for your context and aims: When choosing plant family combinations and species, start by investigating the issues and constraints that are preventing you from achieving your goals. What are the current limitations to your soil health? Think about soil structure, biology and nutrients. For example, do you have compaction, high aluminium levels or little signs of soil life? Choose plants that are likely to help you address those constraints. Also think about plants that would do well in your environment. Take into account what’s already in the paddock, and try to choose plants that complement what’s already there. In the case of weeds, it’s worth trialling beneficial plants from the same family as the dominant weed species in a bid to outcompete them while also fulfilling the ecological role of that weed. If the weed is doing well in your soil conditions, a more desirable plant from the same species may well thrive. See Episode 7 of the Soils for Life podcast.
Choosing plant mixes can be complex and imprecise, and something that many farmers report getting better at over time with observation and monitoring. If unsure, go for diversity. It’s often advised to choose a mix of plants suited to your environment from a minimum of four different plant families, preferably six. Another way to create diversity is to choose plants that have different canopy heights and leaf structures to support greater photosynthetic capacity and biomass production within the crop (see Appendix 1, 2 and 3 for common annual plant families for different seasons). And make sure to consider whether annuals or perennials are right for your context (see Annuals and perennials section below).
When deciding on plant mixes, Grant Sims considers the situation of a given paddock, including the state of the soils and his end goals, such as increasing nutrient access, weed suppression and animal health. For example, he might choose tillage radish to help break hardpans, scavenge for nitrogen and discourage disease.
Grant’s general rule is to aim for a minimum of eight different plant species from at least four different plant families (but preferably six), with only one species from the grass family. This allows diverse root systems that together access a large soil area.
Ian Beard has experimented with many mixes, and his approach is to grow an ‘affordable multispecies cover crop suited to our soils and area’. While he’s developed reliable summer and winter mixes, he often tries ‘anything and everything’, including sorghum, millet, sunflower and even horse and bird seed mixes. He recommends sourcing what is locally available at a good price and trying to keep at least three families in the mix: a cereal, a brassica and a legume. He says the ratio of plant families depends on the end goal. For example, you might want to increase brassicas and legumes and decrease cereals if your end goal is to reduce compaction. Ian loves incorporating oats in his winter mix because they’re a ‘tremendous phosphorus builder’ along with cereal rye. He doesn’t use wheat or barley in his mixes because he prefers to keep his main cash crops separate. For brassicas, he’s a big fan of using ‘tillage’ radish and forage canola, and for legumes he sees good results from field peas and vetch.
Initially, Rob Hetherington’s plant choices were based on ‘gut feeling’ and what was most accessible to him. For his winter mix he chose seven different species that included legumes, a brassica and cereals: sowing wheat, barley, cereal rye, faba beans, lupins, peas and a bit of canola. The results were good so he continued with the mix, adding vetch over the years.
Annuals and perennials: Annuals are a great way to establish a multispecies crop and it’s a good idea to get these going before introducing perennials into your system. This comes down to your soil health and plant succession. Often annual weeds indicate a paddock is more degraded and therefore suitable to earlier succession plants. As pioneer species, annuals tend to do better in these conditions than perennials. If perennials are compatible with your cropping rotation, enterprise mix or future goals and you were to add perennials at this stage, they would require a lot of management which could be costly.
Image 7. Multispecies at Walma farm in 2024. Source: Soils for Life.
Grant Sims advises farmers to consider their soil and plant succession as linked because the state of your soil microbial community can influence plant succession. ‘Are you finding lots of weeds and things like that in your soil due to soil structure problems?’ If so, he suggests starting with high diversity annuals at a lower seed and management cost than perennials to help prime the soil. According to agronomist Mark Tupman, perennials can offer good feed over the year, are hardy once established, and can build soil at depth, but he agrees that they can be hard to establish and it’s a good idea to build soil fertility with annuals first.
Summer and winter mixes: Deciding whether to plant summer (also called warm season) or winter (cool season) mixes (or both) depends on your context. While multispecies crops can be more drought resilient than monoculture crops, you still need to consider soil moisture.
Grant Sims tries to increase plant diversity across the season with a mix of summer and winter season plants. Grant’s view is that winter cover crops are ‘a no brainer’ in his context, but that cover crops can work in any season depending on the conditions. He is opportunistic about when and where to sow a summer cover crop, and says that the important thing is to have a goal that matches the seasonal conditions and factors in flexibility (e.g. if the season turns out worse than expected, having alternative uses for less than perfect crops).
In Rob Hetherington’s case, he has decided to focus on winter cover crops. He originally tried a summer multispecies crop to spread the workload through the year and get in a C4 summer active plant (millet), but with an average rainfall of 330 mm, the minimal summer rain hasn’t led to great results. He also has learned to sow the winter multispecies crop in April so it establishes before the ryegrass takes hold.
With more reliable summer rainfall in south eastern Queensland, Ian Beard grows both summer and winter crops.
Rotations: Whether your multispecies crop is part of a set rotation or not depends on the function of the multispecies crop, your system and whether you need to be opportunistic with rainfall and soil moisture.
For Ian Beard in his 100% cropping system, multispecies crops are part of a set rotation. Wheat is followed by mung beans, then barley followed by buckwheat or chickpea and then by sorghum, then back to a winter multispecies cover crop and a summer multispecies cover crop, and finally back to wheat. Ian dedicates 32 ha to cash crops and 32 to multispecies cover crops at any one time.
Grant Sims tends to consider multispecies crops where a paddock ‘needs a spell’ because of weed pressure, fertility issues and other soil limitations such as compaction, flooding or low carbon levels. He’ll leave the paddock out of the main crop, include a cover crop to build fertility, get on top of weeds and build organic matter, with animal impact through grazing. He’ll then return the paddock to a cash crop, finding it grows better having had a spell.
Rob Hetherington’s rotation generally starts with a legume, sometimes combined with a brassica (to clean up the paddock so the ryegrass doesn’t take hold), followed by wheat or barley, and then two years of multispecies crops including a summer cover if the season allows.
Want more detail on choosing seed mixes? Check out our extensive tables of plant families and common species and characteristics for much more information.
Giving the crop a good start
Like any other crop, multispecies cropping benefits from a good start, with timely planting for seasonal breaks and available moisture. When preparing a paddock, you might want to weigh up weed management options and nutritional and biological support. Other considerations include soil-to-seed contact, protection from wildlife, sufficient moisture, suitable temperature and pest/disease control.
Preparing your paddock: Two common approaches to weed management when preparing a paddock for a multispecies crop are mechanical (e.g. grazing, tillage, slashing, roller crimping) and chemical (e.g. application of a knock down herbicide prior to sowing).
With animals in his system, Grant Sims uses either animals or glyphosate (buffered with fulvic acid) on a paddock prior to sowing and likes to start with his ‘cleanest’ paddock. ‘If we sow into a paddock with weed problems then by the time the seed germinates the existing weeds are a week or two above and starting to photosynthesise better and pump sugars, so these will be the dominant ones in the mix, especially allelopathic22Allelopathy is a biological phenomenon in which one plant can affect the growth, survival and/or reproduction of another plant. See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9742440/ weeds,’ says Grant.
Rob Hetherington prepares the paddock in the same way he would any other winter crop. He sprays out problem weeds such as ryegrass with herbicide, adding a couple litres of fish, fulvic acid and a biostimulant, which can improve the efficacy of the chemical and assist in cycling nutrients.
Managing herbicide use: When using herbicide as part of their multispecies crop rotation, some farmers have found ways to use less or buffer its impact.
Ian Beard has found that over time he has had to use less herbicide with multispecies crops in the system. He says reducing chemicals is a real balancing act and he’s had to learn to get the timing right. For Grant, using chemicals is about weighing things up, and that ‘it’s one step back for ten steps forward’.
Some farmers use amendments to help buffer the impact of herbicide on biology and improve plant uptake.23See, for example “Reducing chemical requirements” in Graeme Sait’s article “Chasing the Biggest Bang – Ten Tips to Reduce Input Costs,” Nutri-Tech Solution, accessed August 2024, https://blog.nutri-tech.com.au/chasing-the-biggest-bang/ For example, Rob uses fulvic acid, biological stimulants and amino acids with his herbicide applications. Ian regularly applies biological brews in combination with bacterial and fungal foods to support soil biology. He also applies a small amount of gypsum (150 kg/ha) after every cash or multispecies crop because he understands the role that calcium plays in supporting soil health. See our guide to reducing herbicide (out soon).
Preparing and sowing the seed
Seeding ratios and rates: Once you have chosen a mix of plant species, you need to figure out how much of each seed is required. Like many other aspects of multispecies cropping, this can depend on your context and may require some trial and error. Seeding rates of a species can vary, with Grant, Rob and Ian seeding at rates that range from 0.5 kg/ha to 21 kg/ha (see Tables 1, 2 and 3).
Table 1. Example of seeding rates and ratios of Grant Sims’s winter super mix, colour coded by plant family.
Table 2. Example of seeding rates and ratios of Ian Beard’s summer mix, colour coded by plant family.
Table 3. Example of seeding rates and ratios of Rob Hetherington’s winter mix, colour coded by plant family.
When it comes to seeding rates, less is often more to ensure plants aren’t overcrowded and can reach their optimum structure and physiology. Visualise what you want a square metre of your multispecies cover crop to look like (e.g. how dense do you want it? What kinds of plant dynamics?) and then work back to figure out your seeding rate. It is often a matter of trial and error to figure out what suits your context.
Seeding rates might need to be adjusted to the conditions, including climate, season and soil type. In dry conditions, many farmers have found high seeding rates can work better because the plants cool the soil down and work together to access moisture. For example, 30–40 kg/ha might be suitable in dry conditions, whilst 10–15 kg/ha might be more suitable in wet, heavy clay soils. Latitude and corresponding climate can also affect seeding rates, with lower seeding rates being suitable in warmer climates. Seeding rates may need to change depending on how you are seeding, as well. For example, broadcasting may need a higher rate than direct drilling.
You may also need to consider ratios for each type of seed in the mix (e.g. agronomist Dr Ademir Caligari recommends chenopodiaceae make up less than 1% and brassicaceae less than 5% of your total mix if you’re trying to improve arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi) and the per hectare seeding rate for each seed type.
Mixing the seed may be required depending on how you source your seed, your method of seeding and the seed mix (see Sowing the seed and equipment section below). Rob finds that using a chaser bin with scales is handy for weighing out each individual variety before putting it into one bin for mixing (60 tonne field bin). Knowing the weight is also useful for measuring out the volume of biological seed treatment required, if using. Rob saves most of his seed so this process is useful.
Biological seed treatments: Each of the example farmers treat their seed with a biological treatment and also apply nutrition when sowing.
Rob Hetherington inoculates the whole seed mix with a legume rhizobia inoculant combined with a biological seed treatment of fish emulsion, silica (Maxsil), fulvic, kelp and vermicast (Nutrisoil). He sprays the dressing and inoculant on as the grain is going up the auger into the truck prior to sowing.
Ian Beard treats his seed with a recipe from Graeme Sait24Nutrition Farming podcast by Graeme Sait- https://nutri-tech.com.au/pages/nutrition-farming-podcast and then adds Johnson-Su compost extract. Both recipes are readily available online.25Johnson-Su information- https://www.rcsaustralia.com.au/johnson-su/
Grant Sims likes to put on a biological stimulant comprising minerals and microbes to give the seed an advantage and energy.
Find out more: Biological seed treatments are liquids or powders that can contain microbes, biostimulants and sometimes nutrients or trace minerals to enhance seedling growth and resilience. These treatments can be applied to the seed prior to sowing. Check out our Biological Seed Treatment Practice Guide to learn more, including tips on sourcing untreated seed.
Sowing the seed and equipment: When sowing a multispecies crop, you need to ensure your seeding equipment is capable of handling seeds of different sizes and sowing them at the depths required. For example, some farmers will utilise the small seed box of their seeder to plant the smaller seeds at surface level. Others will utilise the fertiliser box where appropriate, and some farmers simply mix all their seed together and utilise the planter box.
Grant Sims and Ian Beard predominantly use a disc seeder for sowing their multispecies. Rob Hetherington, however, sees better results on his soils using a tyne machine.
Grant mixes his seed together in his disc seeder. This seeder also has a liquid inject system which he uses to deliver guano or biological liquid fertilisers down the tube. He says these inputs provide energy and help plants grow a nice canopy while not being detrimental to soil fungi and biology.
Ian uses a homemade disc seeder with coulters and an air cart (see Image 7), and he is also building a homemade liquid injection unit to apply the Johnson-Su in the farrows.
Rob also sows his seed with a liquid inject system. He uses granulated mono-ammonium phosphate (MAP), guano, sulphate of ammonia (SOA), liquid humics, fulvics, and fish combined with trace elements and biologicals.
Supporting the crop with foliar sprays
Foliar sprays are a common way to support the growth of a multispecies crop. Farmers might respond to visual cues from the crop (e.g. yellowing, purpling, stunting, leaf curl), use a brix meter to gauge plant health and photosynthesis or use plant tissue or sap testing to determine if and when they need to apply a nutrient or biostimulant foliar application.
Rob Hetherington says he could very well leave out the foliar application but he wants to give the plant the best nutrition possible, especially considering the crop will feed dairy cows. He uses a mix of kelp, fish emulsions, fulvic acid, micronised guano and a biological stimulant and applies it usually when the cereals are tillering.
Grant Sims’s view is that healthy plants drive healthy soils, and foliar nutrition is a very cost effective way to correct deficiencies and increase plant health. He uses a range of practices to support his multispecies crop during the growing phase, including foliar applications. The main foliar application is using his home made multi-mineral liquid biofertiliser. This is especially useful during cooler periods when there’s less sunlight to stimulate the plant to photosynthesise more (he monitors this using a brix meter), which stimulates greater levels of root exudates and soil microbial activity. This in turn supports live weight gains for his cattle. He often uses other liquid products including a worm juice (containing Pseudomonas fluorescens) to help protect the plants from frost damage and insect attack, and a lactobacillus probiotic to boost plant defences against disease.
For Ian Beard, foliar applications are a way to reduce his synthetic fertiliser rates. For example, using a foliar of urea mixed with a humic or fulvic acid has helped Ian to reduce his nitrogen bill. When combined with a carbon source, foliar applications of urea can be efficiently absorbed by plants. Soil applications of nitrogen have slower uptake by plants and are more susceptible to leaching.26Joel Williams, “Nitrogen Stabilisers (Part 2): Carbon Inputs,” Direct Driller Magazine 20, (2023): 62-63, https://issuu.com/directdriller/docs/direct_driller_magazine_issue_20/62 Ian also uses sap testing to determine what the plant needs and then tailors the foliar application accordingly.
Harvesting, utilising and terminating the crop
When to harvest, utilise or terminate the crop really depends on how the season is going, your rainfall, whether you’re responding to an opportunistic market and the function of the multispecies crop (i.e. whether it is grazed, harvested for fodder or a cash crop or used purely as a cover crop to be mulched in).
Harvesting a cash crop: Rob Hetherington
Rob harvests the crop when it ripens using the header as he would with any crop. The dairy customer collects the multispecies crop directly from the farm, which doesn’t need to be dried or sorted. Rob recognises that it’s not always so straightforward for farmers looking to sell multispecies grain. When he began growing summer multispecies and wanted to sell the millet as seed, he had to transport it some 250 km away for drying and sorting, adding extra costs.
Utilising the crop for animal feed: Grant Sims
Sometimes Grant lets the animals ‘crash graze’ part of the multispecies paddock while it’s growing. He will set up a temporary fence to split a paddock in two and intensively graze one side early and then graze the next side once it has reached ‘milky dough’ stage (when the grains are filling out). He observes that later grazing can leave more biomass in the system and allow the roots to go deeper, while grazing earlier reduces groundcover and prunes the roots. But sometimes early grazing is useful because ‘animals tugging and pulling on plants can help them produce exudates and help feed back into the soil’. Another method is swath grazing or windrow grazing, where Grant terminates the crop for hay, but instead of baling it, he leaves it in the paddock and strip grazes the windrows. Leaving the hay windrows in a paddock offers feed at the end of the season, holds moisture and helps control weeds because the cattle nip off any unwanted plants that come up.
Grant also suggests waiting until the plants reach 15–20 cm or ‘until you can grab the plant, give it a tug and it won’t pull out the roots,’ before putting the animals in a multispecies crop. He says, ‘be mindful not to graze too heavily because the plants may not grow back.’ He suggests a light graze initially, and depending what you want to do with the crop, you could hit it harder later in the year.
If in a high rainfall environment, Grant suggests letting the crop grow to full maturity before grazing so the roots can go deep and open up the soil and drag out some of the subsoil moisture. But if you’re concerned about conserving subsoil moisture in drier conditions, then he suggests considering terminating at the onset of flowering. If a plant goes on to seed then it drags moisture and minerals out of the soil.
Terminating a cover crop for mulch: Ian Beard
To use the multispecies cover crop as a mulch, Ian likes to let the crop go to flower and sometimes to seed but he will terminate early if they are in severe drought or if he thinks letting it flower or seed might compromise the following cash crop. He uses a homemade double crimp roller and also puts out biology and nutrients at the same time using a biological spray rig with a ‘broad band nozzle’ (see Image 10).
Tips and Tricks
- Get to know your soils and paddocks and think about what each paddock needs to optimise soil health to support the crop. Observing your constraints can help inform your seed choices and potential challenges to establishing a multispecies crop. Use plants suited to the state of your soil and what you want to achieve.
- Get to know your soil chemistry ‘totals’ not just ‘availables’. Multispecies are great at improving nutrient cycling which can help the plant access more nutrients locked up in non-bioavailable forms in the soil.
- Consider if and how you will terminate your multispecies crop and know that some plants may be more difficult to terminate than others. You may need to employ herbicide or mechanical means (cultivation or roller crimping), or you can consider plants in the mix that will terminate with seasonal changes (e.g. frost).
- Sow your multispecies early or terminate weeds prior to sowing to avoid competition with undesirable plants in the same way you would for a cash crop.
- Consider starting with annuals to prime the soil for a few years before adding perennials. Some farmers also prefer older plant varieties because they can have larger root systems and can sometimes function better within a diverse soil microbiome.
- Seed quality is just as important for multispecies mixes as it is for a cash crop, so ask for seed germination and purity results.
- Plan ahead to obtain seed for timely planting, especially when sourcing untreated seed. Seed availability can vary depending on region and type of seed.
- If working with herbicides, consider the likelihood of residues from targeted herbicide on plant families that you’d like to grow in your multispecies mix.
- Consider whether some plants in a multispecies mix could contaminate future crops, and if so, could they be sorted out.
Finances
Costs associated with multispecies can be broken down like any other crop – the cost of seed, paddock preparation, nutritional support and harvest. Depending on the mix you choose and where you source your seed from, the cost of seed can be significant.
The financial benefits of multispecies crops include sales of a harvested crop, however, many of the financial benefits accrue over time (e.g. soil enhancement, livestock fodder, moisture retention, etc.) and can sometimes be difficult to link directly to the multispecies crop.
It’s important to consider the potential short and long term benefits of the multispecies crop and how these stack up against the costs in your unique context and goals. For this reason, it may make sense to start small and experiment before implementing at a larger scale.
The basic costs per hectare of Ian’s multispecies seed, seed and plant treatment and associated operations are outlined in Table 4.27Costs can vary depending on price fluctuation and Ian sources some of his seed from fellow farmers. Ian Beard estimates the costs for seed and plant treatment and operations to be $150/ha per crop. He often plants cash crops into this preparation without fertiliser, and he says ‘this method can be comparable in costs with a long fallow, while gaining soil health.’28 Ian’s two year dryland crop rotation involves a winter multispecies cover crop, a summer multispecies cover crop, followed by two back-to-back cash crops (e.g. wheat and mung beans). Before rotating into a multispecies phase and straight after harvesting a cash crop, Ian likes to put on gypsum. Ian uses a biological seed treatment to prepare the seeds. He likes to plant these into a clean seed bed, sometimes using a glyphosate application. As the crop grows, Ian will assess when to put on foliar applications. After terminating with a roller crimper, slasher or offset disc, he begins this process again for the next multispecies crop in the rotation.
Table 4. A guide to Ian Beard’s back-to-back multispecies cropping program costs prior to planting a cash crop. Source: Adapted from Ian Beard’s, ‘A Guide only for General Costs for Regenerative Agriculture Practices’.
Grant Sims has two options for harvesting and seeing immediate profit from his multispecies crops: cutting hay and grazing with beef cattle (i.e. live weight gain). He estimates that these deliver a profit of between $1,529/ha for cut hay, and $2,625/ha for grazing with beef cattle (see Table 5).
Table 5. Grant Sims’ profit table (per hectare and per animal) for a two-season multispecies crop grazed by cattle (left) and harvested for hay (right), based on 14-way winter mix with 170 mm of growth season rainfall.
Rob Hetherington says the financial gains of his multispecies crops are difficult to define but he believes that they are helping him to achieve his goal of generating soil biology and reducing his nitrogen bill. Rob sells his multispecies grain to a dairy for a price comparable to wheat but without freight costs to bulk handlers. He does have the responsibility of storing the grain on his farm, as well as the costs associated with the bags, bag loader and bag outloader.
Indicators of success
When you’re adopting a new practice, it’s important to monitor for signs to understand whether the practice is worth the time, energy and expense, and to make sure there are no adverse impacts. In order to assess whether multispecies cropping is working within their system, farmers can look at the health of soils, plants and animals, and productivity.
Video 3. Learn more about how farmer Grant Sims monitors his plants and soils for indicators of change after implementing multispeices cropping practices.
Soil health, including better soil structure, soil function and biological activity, can come with the greater plant and root diversity of a multispecies crop.
Plant health is a good indicator as to whether a multispecies crop is serving the purpose it was intended for. All three farmers use a refractometer (brix meter) to measure the level of total dissolved solids, which include mostly sugars but also vitamins, minerals, and other soluble compounds, in a liquid such as the sap from the leaves and other plant parts. The brix can also be interpreted as an indication of the nutrient uptake and therefore the health of the plant. All three farmers test before and after applying any inputs to their crop to help assess their effectiveness. Each farmer also looks to plant growth (biomass) and they have observed that biomass in multispecies crops is typically substantially greater than monoculture crops, especially in dry years.
Image 11.Rob Hetherington observing the soil in his multispecies paddock. Source: Grow Love Project.
Animal health and productivity can be key indicators that multispecies cropping is working in the system. Grant looks to his animals for positive indicators and has noted better livestock weight gains (1.7kg–2 kg/day) on his cattle. He says, ‘we’ve done live weight gains on windrow strip grazing, on grazing the covers, on bale grazing hay etc., and what we’re finding is really good live weight gains. We’re weighing cows and calves and they’re both putting on good weight.’ He also notes that they are seeing significant liveweight gains even when the cows have calves on them (1–1.5 kg/day). He is also finding an improvement in animal temperament, fertility (97.5% pregnancy tested in calf), and they don’t take long to ‘get their gut fill. They go in, have a feed and bang – they’re lying down for half a day … and that comes down to nutrient density.’
Multispecies feed grown by Rob in 2021 had 1.4% grain lipid fat content and when Rob fertilised the crop it went to 4.4% – an example of making the most of the multispecies crop by looking after it. The dairy also noted an increase in the quantity of milk without compromising protein and butterfat, and an overall improvement in animal health indicated by lower somatic cell count leading to lower levels of mastitis.
Grant Sims uses a range of monitoring strategies, including lab tests, a penetrometer, a shovel to dig up soil for visual inspection, a microbiome meter to measure microbial activity and also regular water infiltration tests. Grant also looks at the total pool of nutrients in the soil, including nutrients in a non-plant-available form. Improving soil biology (through planting multispecies crops for example) can help to increase the availability of these nutrients.
Ian Beard has seen a huge turnaround in the soils on his property since using multispecies crops in his program. He has seen improvement in compaction issues and observes that he now has more oxygenated soils. Ian has seen a flow-on effect of the multispecies cover crops and complementary practices in less weed pressure, more drought tolerance and better grain.
Rob Hetherington has noticed that in his multispecies paddocks the soil has softened up and the soil aggregation has improved. These observations are supported by 2022 soil test results,29For details on soil tests see Rob’s Soils for Life case study, ‘Deeper insights – soil and landscape’: https://soilsforlife.org.au/walma/#progress which indicated that the multispecies sites, along with companion crop sites, are Rob’s healthiest soils. The above average soil respiration30Soil respiration is a measure of the carbon dioxide (CO2) released from soil. It is an indicator of soil health because it measures the level of microbial activity and the content and decomposition of soil organic matter. See “Soil Respiration: Soil Health Guide for Educators,” United States Agriculture, Natural Resources Conservation Services, accessed September 5, 2024, https://www.nrcs.usda.gov/sites/default/files/2022-10/Soil%20Respiration.pdf and moderate microbial activity identified by these tests can positively influence nutrient cycling, the building of soil organic matter and soil aggregation.
Find out more: Check out our cropping case studies and other practice guides to see what other practices farmers are implementing to build soil health and farm resilience.
Further learning
Explore our series of practice guides
Next guides coming soon!
Follow us on socials, or sign up to our newsletter to hear about our next releases!
Multispecies Cropping
Check out our ‘how to’ video series on Multispecies Cropping. Farmer Grant Sims shares why he started and how de does it.
Resources and tips recommended by the farmers in this guide
Informative and inspiring people
- Graeme Sait, QLD educator and co-founder of Nutri-Tech Solutions (specifically the ‘Nutrition Farming’ course)
- Elaine Ingham, founder Soil Food Web
- Arden Anderson, US teacher, physician, consultant of biological farming
- Garry Zimmer, US farmer
- Hugh Lovell, QLD author, film maker, advisor, see Farming Secrets profile
- Christine Jones, AUST founder Amazing Carbon
- Kevin Elmy, Canada author Cover Cropping in Western Canada
- Steve Groff, US farmer, researcher and consultant
- Jill Clapperton
- Nicole Masters, agroecologist and coach, Integrity Soils
- Neil Kinsey, soil fertility consultant, Kinsey Agricultural Services
- Joel Williams, plant and soil health educator, Integrity Soils
Useful resources
- Greencover seeds in the USA: a really good resource, although it requires some translating to the Australian context.
- Cover Crop Candidates – Mixed Cover Crops for Sustainable Farming (csiro.au) by Jenny Stanton
Other resources from Soils for Life
Join a discussion group
Learn from other like minded farmers in one of our Cropping Discussion groups or follow our guide to start your own.
Listen to the Soils for Life Podcast
Check out our podcast interview with Joel Williams on small steps for big change in cropping.
What did you think of this guide?
Thank you for reading the practice guide! We would love to know whether you found the guide useful. Please take a minute tell us more.
This project is jointly funded through the Australian Government’s Future Drought Fund and Soils for Life.
For more information
If you have any questions, get in touch at [email protected].